The Vampire Diaries Missed Out On The Perfect Spinoff (But It Can Still Happen)

August 31, 2024

Even though The Vampire Diaries originated two other series, the show missed out on using the perfect spinoff idea that, luckily, can still happen.

Summary

A spinoff focused on Jeremy's life as a vampire hunter would have been the perfect choice for The Vampire Diaries.
Julie Plec could still make a Jeremy spinoff, as actor Steven R. McQueen has previously expressed interest and isn't attached to other long-term TV shows or franchises.
A Jeremy spinoff would be better than a Legacies spinoff, as it would appeal to fans of the original series and potentially regain the audience that Legacies lost.

The Vampire Diaries missed out on the perfect spinoff, but the overlooked idea could still happen seven years after the series went off the air. Adapted from the novels by L.J. Smith, The Vampire Diaries ran on the CW from 2009 to 2017, gaining a massive following. This success allowed creator Julie Plec to produce The Originals, a show within the same shared universe following the original family. This series took a more mature perspective and a darker storytelling method, distinguishing it from the teenage Vampire Diaries’ characters and high school setting.

Since both The Originals and The Vampire Diaries found success with audiences, Plec decided to create Legacies, a second spinoff following the next generation of witches, werewolves, and vampires. The series centered on the experiences and perspectives of Hope Mikaelson, Lizzie Saltzman, and Josie Saltzman. While all the shows were entertaining, Plec missed out on creating the perfect Vampire Diaries spinoff.

All 8 The Vampire Diaries Seasons, Ranked Worst To Best

Unlike many other shows, The Vampire Diaries does not decline in quality as the series goes on – its memorable characters are scheming until the end.

Jeremy’s Life As A Hunter Would’ve Been The Perfect Vampire Diaries Spinoff

Throughout The Vampire Diaries, Jeremy grew as a character, becoming more self-assured and outspoken. Jeremy hit his stride when he became one of The Five. This gave him a more significant purpose within the bigger picture of The Vampire Diaries. He thrived when hunting vampires – an impulse he never lost when he was no longer one of the Five. When Jeremy exited in The Vampire Diaries season 6, it seemed like it was trying to introduce a spinoff following the character’s life as a vampire hunter. Steven R. McQueen even joked at the time about being open to the idea.

A Jeremy spinoff would have been the perfect choice because Jeremy had outgrown Mystic Falls, but that didn’t mean fans stopped caring about him. A spinoff could’ve explored his vampire hunting outside the confines of his hometown. He would’ve had ample room to continue his character growth and show what vampires look like elsewhere. Unfortunately, this spinoff never came to fruition, likely because the CW already had two shows within the same universe.

Julie Plec Could Still Make A Jeremy Spinoff

Since Julie Plec still wants to create another Vampire Diaries spinoff after Legacies, this opens the door to a show focused on Jeremy’s life as a vampire hunter. Actor Steven R. McQueen reprised his role once in Legacies, indicating that he may be open to playing Jeremy again. Additionally, McQueen isn’t presently attached to any other long-term TV shows or franchises, meaning there wouldn’t be career barriers preventing him from committing to a spinoff.

After leaving The Vampire Diaries , Steven R. McQueen acted in the action/drama TV show Chicago Fire .

Additionally, Jeremy’s exit did most of the heavy lifting by laying the foundation for the spinoff show. Jeremy left to hunt vampires in Santa Fe, and Alaric said he would send more locations. Obviously, the spinoff would need to take place later in the timeline since seven years have passed since the show finished, but this still creates a strong premise to work off of while offering ample room for creative freedom. Plus, characters from the original show or two spinoffs could have guest roles on the show, allowing for other familiar faces.

Most importantly, a Jeremy spinoff doesn’t have as many limitations as most potential Vampire Diaries spinoffs. Because he isn’t a vampire, it doesn’t matter that time has passed since the original show. His aging isn’t an issue for the narrative integrity. Except for Bonnie, Jeremy is the most beloved Vampire Diaries character who doesn’t face this potential problem. Since The Vampire Diaries’ Kat Graham said she wouldn’t return, Jeremy is the best choice from the original cast to lead a new spinoff.

The Vampire Diaries: Every Time A Character Returned After Their Death

The Vampire Diaries is notorious for killing off its characters and bringing them back after their deaths, even if it’s just as ghosts or spirits.

A Jeremy Spinoff Would Be Better Than A Legacies Spinoff

If Plec followed through on making a new spinoff, there would be a few possible directions she could go. The most obvious option would be to create a spinoff from Legacies, the newest addition to the Vampire Diaries universe. However, this would be a massive mistake. Firstly, most of the characters in this show also have the same age limitations as characters from the original series. Since actors continue to age while the characters stay put, there’s a built-in time limit on the possible spinoff.

The Jeremy spinoff could gain back the audience that Legacies lost.

Additionally, many fans of The Vampire Diaries and The Originals didn’t like Legacies. They felt like the characters weren’t as compelling, and the show was too campy. A series focusing on a character from Legacies would bring in a smaller audience than focusing on someone from the original series. The Jeremy spinoff could gain back the audience that Legacies lost. It will also appeal to fans of the original Vampire Diaries series because of the nostalgia factor.

The Vampire Diaries

Cast Nina Dobrev , Ian Somerhalder , Steven R. McQueen , Paul Wesley , Kat Graham , Michael Trevino , Michael Malarkey , Zach Roerig , Candice King , Matthew Davis Franchise The Vampire Diaries Writers Julie Plec , Kevin Williamson , L.J. Smith Directors John Dahl Showrunner Julie Plec Related Topics About The Author